M8 energy & process assessment protocol, Table m4. lcca results for the 15 ecip ecms – Retrotec USACE User Manual
Page 430
M8 ENERGY & PROCESS ASSESSMENT PROTOCOL
The following table provides an example of the LCCA output.
TABLE M4. LCCA RESULTS FOR THE 15 ECIP ECMS.
ECM
Total
Investment
First-Year
Savings
SIR
AIRR
Simple
Payback
(Years)
Annual Usage
Savings (Cost)
(MBtu)
Discounted Savings (Cost) Over Project Life
Total
Operational
Savings
Coal
Electricity
Coal
Electricity
Usage
Electricity
Demand
Total Energy
(Excludes Demand
Savings)
Non-Energy
PL1A
$153,480
$33,556.0
3.84
10.2%
4.57
1,665
1,046
$139,766
$104,725
$244,491
$345,320
$589,811
PL2
$211,960
$82,903.0
5.87
12.5%
2.56
7,908
5,802
$663,824
$581,005
$1,244,829
$1,244,829
PL3
$100,959
$9,590.0
1.42
4.8%
10.53
1,708
0
$143,375
$143,375
$143,375
PL5
$2,511
$5,222.0
31.09
22.3%
0.48
930
0
$78,067
$78,067
$78,067
PL6
$84,831
$8,159.0
1.45
4.9%
10.4
0
888
$88,891
$34,242
$88,891
$123,133
PN1
$79,760
$21,034.0
3.95
10.3%
3.79
2,972
655
$249,480
$65,587
$315,067
$315,067
PN2
$132,430
$21,253.0
2.4
7.6%
6.23
3,122
492
$262,071
$49,276
$6,912
$311,347
$318,259
PN3
$145,860
$114,675.0 11.79
16.5%
1.27
13,386
529
$1,123,665 $53,011
$1,176,676
$543,570
$1,720,247
PN4
$49,650
$63,114.0
19.01
19.3%
0.79
10,971
228
$920,942
$22,816
$943,758
$943,758
WD1
$121,555
$9,184.0
1.13
3.6%
13.24
1,469
123
$123,313
$14,117
$137,430
$137,430
WD2
$15,855
$35,505.0
33.55
22.8%
0.45
4,892
779
$410,651
$78,273
$43,010
$488,924
$531,934
BE1
$273,235
$61,640.0
3.37
9.5%
4.43
10,277
593
$862,686
$59,381
$922,067
$922,067
BE2
$63,950
$43,106.0
10.08
15.6%
1.48
7,677
0
$644,433
$644,433
$644,433
BH9
$2,642
$2,219.0
12.68
17.0%
1.19
0
335
$33,491
$33,491
$33,491
LT1
$72,087
$58,870.0
12.33
16.8%
1.22
0
(170)
$(17,058)
$(17,058)
$905,950
$888,892
Total
$1,510,765
$570,030.0 10.19
16%
2.65
66,977
11,300
Note: All analyses are based on a 20-year life.