Zhivov09_app_b, Continued ) – Retrotec USACE User Manual
Page 125
B1
Appendix B
Examples of Level I Assessment Summary Table
ECM
Description
Investment
(K$)
Savings
(K$/yr)
Payback
(yr)
Savings
Category
Recommended
Funding
Sources
PL#1A, Ph 1
only
Install and test two EED on chrome plat-
ing tanks
153.5
33.6
4.57
E, M
ECIP
PL#1, Ph1 & 2
Install EED on all chrome plating tanks
984.8
251.7
3.91
E, M (S&H)
ECIP
PL#2
Control airfl ows and steam heating
212
82.9
2.56
E
ECIP
PL#3
Insulate hot plating tanks and rinse tanks
101
9.6
10.53
E
ECIP
PL#5
Allow hot plating and rinse tanks to cool
down
2.5
5.2
0.48
E
ECIP
PL#6
Retrofi t MAUs with low pressure drop
fi lters
85
8.1
10.40
E, M
ECIP
PN#1
Enclose Drive-Through Paint Booth #1 in
Bldg. 208
79.8
21.0
3.79
E (P)
ECIP
PN#2
Enclose Drive-Through Paint Booth #2 in
Bldg. 208
132.4
21.3
6.23
E (P)
ECIP
PN#3
B299 Paint Booth 4 improvements
145.9
114.7
1.27
E (P)
ECIP
PN#4
B229 Paint Booth 5 improvements
49.7
63.1
0.79
E (P)
ECIP
HT#5
Heat treat ventilation improvements
168.6
4.6
36.6
E (IAQ)
ESPC
FD#2
Improve foundry ventilation
TBD
TBD
TBD
E (S&H)
ESPC
WD#1
Install ergonomic extraction arms
121.6
9.2
13.24
E (IAQ,P)
ECIP
WD#2
Install improved ventilation system
15.9
35.5
0.45
E (IAQ,P)
ECIP
BE#1
Improve B-220 working conditions and
IAQ
273.2
61.6
4.43
E (TC)
ECIP
BE#2
Install high-speed doors where necessary
64
43.1
1.48
E (TC)
ECIP
BH#1
Improve ventilation in Rapid Response
Mnfc. Cell
17.4
high
quick
E
O&M
BH#6
Install on/off dampers in B-220 supply
air ducts
6
2.5
2.4
E
O&M
BH#8
Improve IAQ in B-299 manufacturing
departments
low
high
quick
E (IAQ)
O&M
BH#9
Perform further energy savings measures
in B-222
2.5
2.2
1.19
E
ECIP
LT#1
Install task lamps in areas requiring ad-
ditional lighting
72.1
58.9
1.22
E (P)
ECIP
FD#1
Replace critical foundry equipment in
B-212 W
744.1
354
2.1
P
WC
18 ECMs
Total of the economically quantifi ed
ECMs, including PL#1 Phase 2 work
3261.1
1149.2
2.84
ALL
ALL
TABLE B1. EXAMPLE LEVEL I ASSESSMENT SUMMARY TABLE
(Continued)