Hwtacacs, Differences between hwtacacs and radius, Basic hwtacacs packet exchange process – H3C Technologies H3C S6300 Series Switches User Manual
Page 22: N in, Figure 5
7
Figure 5 Format of attribute 26
HWTACACS
HW Terminal Access Controller Access Control System (HWTACACS) is an enhanced security protocol
based on TACACS (RFC 1492). HWTACACS is similar to RADIUS, and uses a client/server model for
information exchange between the NAS and the HWTACACS server.
HWTACACS typically provides AAA services for PPP, VPDN, and terminal users. In a typical
HWTACACS scenario, terminal users need to log in to the NAS. Working as the HWTACACS client, the
NAS sends users' usernames and passwords to the HWTACACS server for authentication. After passing
authentication and obtaining authorized rights, a user logs in to the device and performs operations. The
HWTACACS server records the operations that each user performs.
Differences between HWTACACS and RADIUS
HWTACACS and RADIUS have many features in common, such as using a client/server model, using
shared keys for data encryption, and providing flexibility and scalability.
lists their primary
differences.
Table 3 Primary differences between HWTACACS and RADIUS
HWTACACS RADIUS
Uses TCP, which provides reliable network
transmission.
Uses UDP, which provides high transport efficiency.
Encrypts the entire packet except for the HWTACACS
header.
Encrypts only the user password field in an
authentication packet.
Protocol packets are complicated and authorization is
independent of authentication. Authentication and
authorization can be deployed on different
HWTACACS servers.
Protocol packets are simple and the authorization
process is combined with the authentication process.
Supports authorization of configuration commands.
Access to commands depends on both the user's roles
and authorization. A user can use only commands that
are permitted by the user roles and authorized by the
HWTACACS server.
Does not support authorization of configuration
commands. Access to commands solely depends on
the user's roles. For more information about user roles,
see Fundamentals Configuration Guide.
Basic HWTACACS packet exchange process
describes how HWTACACS performs user authentication, authorization, and accounting for a
Telnet user.